Q: I am designing an office complex should I be doing Neher-McGrath calculations?
A: While ever project needs to be analyzed based on it's specific operating perimeters the simple answer is NO. While anytime current is running through a resistance there is heat produced the standard de-rating factors found in NEC 310.16 are more that adequate to compensate for building with standard load factor, like offices. That being said if there are any areas in the building that have a higher than building average load factor then these specific areas should be analyzed.
Q: How much does it cost?
A: Every solution is unique based on many site specific variables. Some solutions will require only a rearrange of conduits in a specific duct bank; others may require larger conductor size, Added Conduits and or a LowRHO backfill. But keeping your conductors within their temperature parameters is not only a requirement if the NEC but it lowers your overall energy use by illuminating some of your I2R losses. In addition, if the ductbank is run directly under the building slab the heat from the conductors will be transferred to the building. This may be beneficial in some specific environments. But in most environments this is heat that will have to be removed from the building. Based on this information providing the correct Neher-McGrath solution can save money over the life of the project.
Q: Will LowRHO® backfill really increase ampacity and save me money?
A: Not always, in some situations LowRHO® is not a good solution. There are many variables that need to be considered. In some conditions the best answer is to modify the duct bank configuration or placement. Ever solution is site specific.
Q: Back as little as 5 years ago these calculations were rarely performed why is an issue now.
A: As rack density get higher and datacenter become fully loaded this is becoming more if an issue. When a datacenter is built the maximum design load is rarely online day one. Typically we see day one loads in the 25-50% range. Over time these loads are increased. A typical data center may not be operating at design load for years after the project is completed. We have been involved in several projects as expert witness and analytical consultants where this exact thing happened. We have seen this repeated and we know that there are still many data centers out there now that are still operating below their design load. As these datacentes hit and run at full load we anticipate this issue to arise.
Q: How will this process affect my construction schedule?
A: If addressed properly and early there will be no affect on construction schedule. It is only where the issue is not addressed that there can be major effects on the schedule. The key is talk about it early in the design process and determine if this is an issue for your project. Most projects like schools, offices, and general commercial project will not be an issue.
Q: How do I determine if I have an issue?
A: Ask yourself these questions:
1. Is this Project a critical environment?
2. Is the design of this project based on a high load factor model?
3. Is the native soil above 90Rho?
4. Is the native soil moisture content below 2%?
5. Will the design call for large duct banks?
If the answer to any of these questions is yes then ask an expert for further review of your project. We can recommend an engineering company that specializes in this type of analysis.
Q: Can i just by some software and do my own calculations?
A: There are abundant software packages sold today that will perform this complex calculation. Some of these systems are very good and some are weak or poorly designed. The package you buy is dependent on the complexity of calculation you need to perform and how much tolerance you have for a steep learning curves and your budget. In addition there are numerous variables that you need to know and understand fully before you can even start the calculation. Lets say you have the software and the required system variable and you do a calculation. Now you have the results and you are half way home. Much like an X-Ray the information is only as good as the Dr. who analyzes it. It takes years to truly understand all of the results and find the best solution. In addition these calculations can only be performed under Engineering Supervision, Per NEC 310.15. We are fixing more and more issues caused by engineers that are not truly qualified to interpret the calculation results. Yes you can do the calculation yourself but with your underground conductors being the life blood of your business, why would you?
Q: Is the Neher-Mcgrath method the only way to calculate underground ampacity?
A: No. Neher-Mcgrath method is the industry standard calculation but there are situation where the Neher-Mcgrath method falls short. The Neher-Mcgrath method is based in ampacity that is static over a given time period. In a Dynamic current situation the Neher-Mcgrath method is a bit conservative. A Dynamic current analysis is best done using the KEMA model. This model is designed for transmission grade power and is applicable to medium voltage and high voltage cables where the operator (typically a utility company) needs to know how much current they can push through a given cable over the next 24 hours.
The model can be used to predict cable temperatures in the future (based on an expected loading) or to calculate the maximum ampacity for the next hours or days. By using these mathematical techniques in a control room setting, for example, the following can be calculated:
The current the cable can transport over the next 24 hours.
The length of time the cable can transport a given ampacity.
The KEMA dynamic thermal model has been comprehensively verified in many situations and in cable types, including oil-filled and polymeric cables in the voltage range from 10 to 150 kV, and installed in various cable environments. Thus, the model is well-suited for use in a cable ampacity management system used to determine on-line circuit loading.
|
|
.: Professional Engineering
Neher-McGrath are specialized and complicated calculations. We highly suggest that all results and calculation be made under the guidance of and licence professional engineer that specializes in this type of work.
NEC 310.15 (C) Engineering Supervision, indicates that these calculations should be performed under engineering supervision.
.: Software:
There are several software packages available that will calculate the Neher-McGrath equations. Each of these packages has its pros and cons. Please feel free to email us with your particular project requirements and we can help you find the software package that best suits your needs. Email Us
.: Professional Articles :
-Heating Pure Power Spring 08
-Duct Bank Heating Calculations
.: DuctShow©:
By downloading you agree that DuctShow© movies are Proprietary and for demonstration purpose only. The information shown in the DuctShow© movies below are NOT applicable to any and all real world installations.
.: Special LowRHO® concrete Mix:
High strength LowRHO® Mix Design
Low strength LowRHO® Mix Design
.: RHOMON® Conduit Thermal Couplings:
RHOMON® Conduit Thermal Couplings are specially engineered pieces of conduit that are placed in your duct bank during installation. These units monitor temperature and can be set up in a self contained system or tied into the building BMS system
|